Almost exactly one month ago, I made the switch from my old, 2g, jailbroken iPhone to a brand new fully legit android phone: the HTC Hero.
My reasons for the switch were varied - it's a platform I'd like to support, hack on and one I generally find interesting. I've also grown increasingly frustrated with my suite of Apple products and, in general, am looking to "live open" (more on that later).
Treats
There are some things that I absolutely love about the Hero: way more than the iPhone:
- It is an aesthetically pleasing device. This is one thing that has kept me on Apple gear for a long time. I appreciate quality design - particularly in the products I use constantly every day. The Hero is a good looking device and feels good in my hand.
- Multi-tasking. Yeah, this is the big "killer feature" over the iPhone, but it's really handy. I consider my phone primarily a communications device and I can see instantly and easily who is emailing, texting, IM'ing or mentioning me on twitter all without quitting the app I'm currently running.
- Contacts a central. On a contact's record, I can see all phone calls, emails and texts with that person - and even their Facebook status (or birthday - nice touch).
- Really great sync. Now, let me start by saying - I'm a google apps user. That said, all I did was add my gmail account information and instantly I had all mail, contacts and calendar entries seemlessly sync'ed to my phone. Oh, and (unlike "mobile me") there was no additional cost.
Frustrations
This isn't quite the ultimate phone yet. Here are my top gripes:
- No paid apps in the Android Market in Canada. I'm confused as to who is really to blame here - whether it's the big US companies or the Canadian government or a combination of the two, but living in Canada can be a real drag sometimes.
- Lag. It's not a blazingly fast phone and when you add running multiple simultaneous apps, the interface can get laggy after a while. A good "task killer" app on Android seems to be a best friend. (I'm currently using TasKiller, FYI).
- Lots of the apps just aren't as good. Twitter apps are a significant comparison - there just is not a tweetie 2 comparable app. That said, there is a google voice app ;-)
- Version lag. This seems to be particularly bad on my HTC Hero (which currently uses Android 1.5), but in general handset manufacturors seem to be slow to roll out the latest version of android for their handsets. Doing so yourself, requires rooting (how is that an advancement from iPhone?).
Conclusion
Overall, though, I'm happy about the switch. I think the Android future is bright and hopefully I'll have some spare time here and there to hack on some things in support of the platform.
Android's value embodied in Google Voice
Android's true value becomes apparent when you factor in the abilities of the native Google Voice app. Multiple that by an order of a magnitude once number portability is available.
I have a bunch of Google Voice invites James, and I would be glad to send you one.
Lots of tips and tricks for Google Voice use in Canada here:
http://www.wifitalk.ca/?p=177
Google Voice is awesome!
Yeah, the ability to actually use Google Voice on my mobile in Canada (which doesn't yet allow forwarding) was another huge plus of moving to Android. I use GV a lot for SMS to the US specifically and allowing the selection of built-in vs. GV is awesome.
Androidin'
Yeah, interface lag and battery life are the two main annoyances with my Ion (although the interface is snappier after upgrading to 1.6). It sounds like speed, at least, is being addressed with the Nexus One.
Hero...
One of the big downsides (in terms of keeping up to date) with the Hero is the "Sense UI" - which I actually like, but it's a layar that HTC needs to maintain.
They've said publicly on twitter that the Sprint Heroes will get 2.1 early in the new year... I hope we're so lucky in Canada...
Applications!
My favourite thing about this thing are the applications that you'd never find anywhere else:
Awesome list!
Yeah, I wanna follow up with the apps that I dig that I've found so far...
Transdroid and NewsRob both sound interesting... I'll check 'em out!
apps
wow, i didn't realize i knew so many android owners! i also just started using newsrob and am quite happy with it. also, i finally found a twitter client i like a few weeks ago, it's called "swift".
will have to figure out the deal with google voice, sounds good!
seriously considering it
I love my iphone... and so does my wife. I was thinking of giving her my iphone and buying another one but the Nexus One is looking really intriguing if only for variety's sake. Better Google apps integration and Google voice would be killer for me.
Opted for iPhone
Call me late for everything, but when my old (non-smart) phone died a few weeks ago I finally jumped on the iPhone bandwagon (after resisting for years). I know a more fervent openness advocate would have gone droid, but I spend enough time dealing with 'platforms' and development on the web – I just want my phone to work and do awesome things without worrying about it, and Apple has that experience sewn up really well. I'm amazed with the quality of the email, web browsing, SocNet apps (Facebook/Twitter/LinkedIn), utility apps that work great with services I already use (Dropbox, Evernote, 1Password, Aardvark, etc.)
I'm definitely starting to see the limitations of the single-tasking paradigm, but that focus and simplicity is one thing I'm really enjoying about the iPhone vs the desktop. (I had given up on Facebook/Twitter because they were just too distracting while I was on the MacBook, but I've come to love them on the iPhone.)
Really missing the lack of a Google Voice app for iPhone – this is the main reason I'm not giving out my GV # as my main number at this point. In general, Apple needs to open up the iPhone APIs to make VOIP clients 1st-class citizens on the iPhone - integration with the dialer, visual voicemail, etc.
All that said, I am watching the Android platform with interest, and and very happy about the strong competition with Apple. Looking forward to reading your further posts on this.